Listing provided courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty- MLS# 237231
Images
Request Info16 May StreetSt Augustine, FL 32084
Single Family · 4 Beds · 4 Full Baths · 1 Half Bath · 5,272 Sq. ft. | 0.28 Acres$900,000
Closed
Closed on 12/18/2023
16 May Street Overview
- Visits:
- 6
Indulge in the captivating splendor of Pillars Castle: a harmonious blend of heritage and opulence. Prepare to be transported to a realm of timeless allure, where history intertwines seamlessly with luxury. Once the residence of the esteemed sculptor, C. Adrian Pillars, this Moorish castle constructed between 1917-1924 is a living masterpiece, having witnessed the creation of iconic sculptures, including the renowned Life circa 1920. While preserving its rich historical legacy, Pillars Castle embraces modernity in its meticulously renovated kitchen. This culinary haven features top-tier stainless steel appliances, a farmhouse sink, a dedicated coffee bar, and an expansive center island and peninsula bar. The Grand Hall exemplifies a distinguished gathering space, featuring a soaring two-story ceiling and a dramatic staircase. Effortlessly host and entertain guests in the refined dining area, adorned with stained glass windows that evoke a sense of a bygone era.
Love this property?
Create a profile so you can receive updates on this property as soon as they happen!
View Map
16 May Street Facts & Features
- Type Single Family
- Sq. ft. 5,272
- Price/Sq.ft. $171
- Lot 0.28 Acres
Details
General
Association/HOA
- Association: No
School Information
- Elementary School: Ketterlinus
- Middle Or Junior School: Sebastian
- High School: St. Augustine
Building Information
- New Construction: No
- Year Built: 1925
Location/Region
- County Or Parish: St. Johns
- MLS Area Major: 03
- Subdivision Name: Nelmar Terrace
Rent/Lease Information
- Lease Term: No Minimum
Tax Information
- Tax Annual Amount: $16,942.13
- Tax Year: 2022
General Information
- Parcel Number: 154060-0000
- Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
- Property Type: RESIDENTIAL
- Zoning: RES
Interior
Beds/Baths
- Bathrooms Full: 4
- Bathrooms Half: 1
- Bedrooms Total: 4
General Information
- Cooling: Central, Electric
- Entry Level: GROUND LEVEL
- Entry Location: Ground Level
- Flooring: Carpet, Tile, Wood
- Heating: Central, Electric
- Living Area: 5272
- Stories: 3
- Stories Total: 1-3
Exterior
Parking Information
- Parking Features: 1 Car Carport, 2 Car Garage, Detached
Lot Information
- Lot Size Acres: 0.28
- Lot Size Area: 1/4 to 1/2 Acre
- Lot Size Dimensions: 76x158
- Water Source: City
Waterfront/View
- Waterfront: No
Building Exterior/Construction
- Architectural Style: Historic
- Construction Materials: Concrete Block
- Roof: Membrane
General Information
- Sewer: Sewer
16 May Street Neighborhood
Community
32084 (St Augustine) Demographics
43
Median Age
699
Population Density (per sq. mile)
37%
College Educated
$54,519
Estimated Median Income
8,998
Estimated Total Home Owners
4,013
Estimated Total Renters
69% / 31%
Estimated Owner / Renter Divide
3
Estimated Average Household Size
Schools
School data unavailable, School data courtesy of LiveBy, Inc. School ratings are based on a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the highest rating and 1 being the lowest rating.16 May Street Market Data
Based on the last 30 days in this zip code
$594,272
Average List Price
$353
Average Price per Square Foot
131
Properties Sold
116
Average Days on Market
597
Properties for Sale
16 May Street History
| Date | Value | Agent |
|---|---|---|
| 6/15/2026Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS | $1,495,000 -3.5% |
Bonne Jones Listing Agent |
| 3/25/2026Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS | $1,550,000 -1.0% |
Bonne Jones Listing Agent |
| 2/14/2026Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS | February 14, 2026 |
Bonne Jones Listing Agent |
| 12/19/2023Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS | Closed |
Steve Markfeld Listing AgentBonne Jones Selling Agent |
| 12/10/2023Source: St. Johns/St. Augustine MLS | Conting_Accpt Backups |
Steve Markfeld Listing Agent |